HF RTTY vs. WSJT-X JTTY on GNURadio

Introduction

Fig.1 GNURC Testing of RTTY45 & JTTY with BB AWGN

Recently I noticed a very interesting video about a new WSJT-X mode called JTTY (Ref.1). The concept here is a mode similar to RTTY keyboard to keyboard communications but with weak signal detection properties. JTTY is included in the latest test release of WSJT-X 3.2.0-rc1 available on the git hub page under “All Releases” towards the bottom (Ref.2). The DX Zone article is a good overview of the properties of JTTY (Ref.3).

I will use a procedure from a recent post (Ref.4) to compare RTTY and JTTY with baseband AWGN. A simple data test message is read into FLDIGI & WSJT-X to generate Test RTTY45 & JTTY wav files. These test files are played through a GNURC channel with additive baseband Gaussian noise and then into FLDIGI & WSJT-X receivers where the performance is evaluated. This is shown in Figure 1.

RTTY Baseband AWGN Performance

Fig.2 Spectrum of rtty45_test.wav BW10dB=1648-1352=296Hz
Fig.3 GNURC Block Diagram for RTTY45 SNR Measurement
Fig.4 GNURC RTTY45 Signal = 0.64 + Noise = 0.4
Fig.5 FLDIGI Rx RTTY45 Noise = 0.1
Fig.6 FLDIGI Rx RTTY45 Noise = 0.5
Noise_rms =
SNR = 0.64/0.x
Character Errors
Msg = 64 characters
Noise_rms = 0.1
SNR = 8dB
0 errors 100% copy
CER = 0.00
0.4
SNR = 2dB
0 errors 100% copy
CER = 0.00
0.5
SNR = 1.1dB
3 errors = 3/65
CER = 0.05
0.6
SNR = 0.3dB
All errors
CER = 1.00
Fig.7 RTTY45 SNR Results for Noise Stnd Dev 0.1 to 0.6

Figure 2 shows the spectrum of the RTTY45 test message centred at 1500Hz with tone spacing of 170Hz and 10dB BW = 296Hz. Figure 3 shows the GNURC schematic for addition of AWGN. RMS blocks allow measurement of power. The output wav file is sent via VBCable to the input of FLDIGI. Figure 4 shows the channel output with noise power std dev = 0.4 and signal power at 0.64. Figures 5/6 show FLDIGI receive with noise of 0.1 & 0.5. Figure 7 shows the performance with errors starting to occur for SNR < 2dB.

JTTY Baseband AWGN Performance

Fig.8 Spectrum of jtty_test.wav BW10dB=1631-1452=179Hz
Fig.9 GNURC Block Diagram for JTTY SNR Measurement (+Opt Pad)
Fig.10 GNURC JTTY Signal = 0.5 + Noise = 0.4
Fig.11 WSJT-X JTTY Rx Noise = 0.1
Fig.12 WSJT-X JTTY Rx Noise = 0.1
Fig.13 WSJT-X JTTY Rx Noise = 0.8
Noise_rms =
SNR = 0.50/0.x
Character Errors
Msg = 64 characters
Noise_rms = 0.1
SNR = 7dB
0 errors 100% copy
CER = 0.00
0.5
SNR = 0dB
0 errors 100% copy
CER = 0.00
7.0
SNR = -11.5dB
0 errors 100% copy
CER = 0.00
8.0
SNR = -12.0dB
5 errors/64
CER = 0.08
11.0
SNR = -13.4dB
All Errors/64
CER = 1.00
Fig.14 JTTY SNR Results for Noise Stnd Dev 0.1 to 11.0

Figure 8 shows the spectrum of the JTTY test message centred at 1500Hz with 10dB BW = 179Hz. Figure 9 shows the GNURC schematic for addition of AWGN. RMS blocks allow measurement of power. The output wav file is sent via VBCable to the input of WJXT-X. Note inclusion of a variable opt pad so as not to overdrive WSJT-X. Figure 10 shows the channel output with noise power std dev = 0.4 and signal power at 0.50. Figures 11/12 show WSJT-X receive with noise of 0.1. Figure 13 shows WSJT-X receive with noise of 0.8. Figure 14 shows the performance with errors starting to occur for SNR <= -11.5dB.

RTTY vs. JTTY AWGN Performance

Comparing the performance of RTTY45 and JTTY we can see a difference in SNR thresholds of 2dB & -11.5dB = 13.5dB which is considerable!

Fig.15 YouTube Video HF RTTY vs. WSJT-X JTTY on GNURadio
HF Amateur Radio Blog Topics

HF Radio Telecommunications Learn by Simulation

Please send your comments, questions and suggestions to:
contact:

YouTube Channel
YouTube Channel

References

#1. – “JTTY Don’t Overlook This No Compromise Digital Mode”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U01AktAezqk

#2. – “WSJT-X Official Home”
https://github.com/WSJTX/wsjtx/releases

#3. – “JTTY Digital Mode: WSJT-X 3.2 Brings RTTY-Style Speed”
https://www.dxzone.com/jtty-digital-mode-wsjt-x/

#4. – “HF SSB vs. Digital Voice Radio AutoEncoder RADE”
https://jeremyclark.ca/wp/telecom/hf-ssb-vs-digital-voice-radio-autoencoder-rade/


By Jeremy Clark

Jeremy Clark is a Senior Telecommunications Engineer and Advanced Amateur Radio Operator VE3PKC. He is the author of E-Books on Telecommunications, Navigation & Electronics.